‘The Poor Always Pay When There’s Austerity’

Friday Facts
May 14th, 2015 by Leave a Comment

Arthur Brooks of the American Enterprise Institute participated in a May 12, 2015 panel discussion on poverty. Panelists at the Georgetown University event included President Obama. Read the transcript of the entire discussion here, from the White House; below are some of Brooks’ comments:

Brightworth President Ray Padron, AEI President Arthur C. Brooks, GPPF President Kelly McCutchen at a 2012 Policy Briefing Luncheon Brooks keynoted for the Georgia Public Policy Foundaiton
(From left) Brightworth President Ray Padron, American Enterprise Institute President Arthur C. Brooks, and Georgia Public Policy Foundation President Kelly McCutchen at a 2012 Policy Briefing Luncheon Brooks keynoted in Atlanta for the Georgia Public Policy Foundation.

MR. BROOKS: Look, no good economist, no self-respecting person who understands anything about economics denies that there are public goods. There just are public goods. We need public goods. Markets fail sometimes — there’s a role for the state. There are no radical libertarians up here, libertarians who believe that the state should not exist, for example. Even the libertarians don’t think that. So we shouldn’t caricature the views of others because, in point of fact, that impugns the motives.

I think that what we’re talking about is, one, when are there public goods? When can the government provide them? And when are the benefits higher than the costs of the government proving these things? Because, in point of fact, when we don’t make cost-benefit calculations at least at the macro level about public goods, the poor pay. This is a fact.

If you look at what’s happening in the periphery countries of Europe today, as George W. Bush used to say, this is a true fact. (Laughter.) It’s more emphasis. There’s nothing wrong. (Laughter.) If you don’t pay attention to the macro economy and the fiscal stability, you will become insolvent. And if you become insolvent, you will have austerity. And if you have austerity, the poor always pay. Jim Wallis taught me this. . The rich never pay. The rich never are left with the bill. It’s the poor who are left with the bill.

So if you join me in believing the safety net is a fundamental, moral right, and it’s a privilege of our society to provide, you must avoid austerity and you must avoid insolvency. And the only way that you can do that is with smart policies.

And I’m 100 percent sure the President agrees with me about smart macro-economic public policies, so I’m not caricaturing these views either. Although can you believe he said “Obama phone”? (Laughter.) And he’s against the Obama phone. So let’s stipulate to that. (Laughter.) Just because they took away his phone. (Laughter.)

Now, since we believe that there should be public goods, then we’re really talking about the system that provides them and provides them efficiently. The President talked about the changing structure of the income distribution, and it’s unambiguously true. What I would urge us to regret is this notion that it’s not a shift, but a transfer. It’s not a transfer.

Since the 1970s, it’s not that the rich have gotten richer; because the poor have gotten poorer. The poor are not having their money taken away and given to the rich. The rich have gotten richer faster than the poor have moved up. And we might be concerned with that because that also reflects on opportunity. And as an opportunity society, as an equal opportunity society, we should all be really concerned with that.

But the extent that we can get away from this notion that the rich are stealing from the poor, then we can look at this in I think in a way that’s constructive. Why? Because the rich are our neighbors and the poor are our neighbors, and everybody else should be our neighbors and they’re all our kids. And I think getting away from that rhetoric is really important.

And then the last point, actually, as we come to consensus is remembering that capitalism or socialism or social democracy or any system is just a system. Look, it’s just a system. It’s just a machine. It’s like your car. You can do great good with it, you can do great evil with it. It can’t go uninhibited. So far it can’t drive on its own. It will soon enough. The economy never will be able to.

Capitalism is nothing more than a system, and it must be predicated on right morals. It must be. Adam Smith taught me that. Adam Smith, the father of modern economics — he wrote “The Wealth of Nations,” in 1776 — 17 years before he wrote “The Theory of Moral sentiments,” which was a more important book because it talked about what it meant as a society to earn the right to have free enterprise, to have free economics. And it was true then, and it’s still true today.

So this is why this conference is so important. This conversation with the President of the United States is so important, from my point of view — I say with appropriate humility — is because we’re talking about right morality toward our brothers and sisters, and built on that, that’s when we can have an open discussion to get our capitalism right. And then the distribution of resources is only a tertiary question. (Applause.)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

I wanted to publicly say how much I appreciate Georgia Public Policy Foundation.  For those of you that will be entering the Legislature or are relatively new you may not quite yet appreciate how much we rely on Georgia Public Policy Foundation’s research and work.  As you know we’re a citizen’s legislature.  We have very little staff. They have been an invaluable, invaluable resource to us.  To put this [Forum] on and the regular programs that they do throughout the year make us better at what we do. (At the 2012 Georgia Legislative Policy Forum.)

Speaker Pro Tem Jan Jones more quotes