Status Quo 1, Students 0

February 8th, 2012 by 2 Comments

By Kelly McCutchen

The Georgia House of Representatives today voted down a Constitutional Amendment clarifying the state’s role in education. This was in response to the Georgia Supreme Court’s ruling last year giving local school boards exclusive control over education. The amendment would also have rescued the hundreds of students in high-performing public schools authorized by the state over the last few years – schools that are doomed to go out of business without a long-term solution.

The arguments against the amendment included concerns about diverting money away from local school systems and that giving parents the opportunity to choose an alternative school would impinge upon local control.

Although it sounds like a debate about allowing vouchers for private schools, that was not the case.

The amendment only allows the state to authorize and fund public charter schools. These are public schools funded with tax dollars operating within the public school framework: charter schools must be non-sectarian; must (given space available) accept every child on a first-come, first-served basis, must not charge tuition;, must follow state curriculum standards; must participate in state testing; must provide transparent financial disclosures; and must comply with all health, safety and civil rights laws.

This will not have an impact for the students in families who can afford to move to a “good” school district or afford to pay for private school tuition. The victims will be poor and disadvantaged students who are struggling at their designated school and have no other option.

In Georgia last year, there were over 70 high schools where over 50 percent of the ninth graders did not come back for 10th grade. This is not acceptable. The children stuck in these schools deserve another option, even if their local school board doesn’t want to provide it.

Education is the great equalizer in our society. Too many Georgia children are being denied that opportunity. It’s time to stop focusing on the needs of adults and start focusing on what is in the best interest of students.

2 thoughts on “Status Quo 1, Students 0

  1. Kelly:

    The title of your article should be Taxpayers 1, Unsupervised Schools 0.

    It’s not about the children; it’s about the bill-payers. The current level of supervision of charter schools by the local boards of education is abysmal. And there appeared to be no funding for the supervision of state chartered schools by the state.

    We all know this dust up started with the failure of the Fulton Science Academy to receive a charter renewal. The North Fulton elected officials been in vapor lock. But the documented facts are that FSA’s management has been arrogant and operated at the edge of the law, perhaps beyond.

    This is not the type of school that deserves any taxpayer funding, regardless of the scores of the students. FYI, this school takes very few if any low income, special needs, or behavior problem kids. Obviously this influences the school’s test results in a very positive manner.

    Again, as your organization clearly editorializes – it’s about the taxpayers.

    1. Marvin,

      Charter schools have triple accountability – local boards, the state board and parents, who can leave at any time. As far as taxpayers are concerned, charter schools receive much less funding than traditonal schools. (Several charter schools have been shut down across the state – I can’t remember when a tradional public school was shut down for lack of performance.) They typically get shorted on the operational funding and receive zero facility funding. Finally, it is against the law for a charter school to deny any students. As opposed to magnet schools, they cannot choose their students. I’m not familiar enough with the situation at FSA to comment on your accusations, but I do know that FSA is one of the highest performing schools in the state and I personally know parents who have kids there who are very satisfied.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

The Georgia Public Policy Foundation has been a catalyst for common sense proposals—and elected officials are listening and reacting.

U.S. Senator Bill Frist more quotes